[linux-dvb] snr on Airstar HD5000?
mkrufky at linuxtv.org
Mon Sep 26 16:32:42 CEST 2005
Geoffrey Hausheer wrote:
>Is there any way to get the SNR with the current drivers for an HD5000?
>I applied Taylor's patch to 18.104.22.168, and had no real problem getting
>my HD5000 up and running. azap returns that a channel lock has
>occurred, and I can record just fine, but azap always reports snr as
>'ffff'. I know that my signal is marginal (I initially set the card
>up in windows, and was only able to squeak out a SNR of ~17 on PBS,
>but this was good enough to get reliable picture and sound). I need
>to go outside and re-aim my antenna (for some reason, I can only get a
>strong signal when my directional all-band is pointed backwards at the
>transmitter), but I'd like to have the SNR available before I do that.
>azap normally shows signal=00000, snr=ffff. ber=00000, unc=000000,
>status=0x1f and flags=FE_HAS_LOCK
>though I'll occasionally see unc jump up a bit.
>I don't want to seem impatient, I am very happy that the card works in
>linux as is, but I'm just wondering if I did something wrong or
>whether these stats aren't available with this card yet.
The issue that you're describing is with the frontend driver, not the
card driver. Mac has written an explanation of why this feature hasn't
Mac Michaels wrote:
>This whole thing is kind of ugly for the lgdt330x chips.
>They do not provide signal strength directly. Thus I do not
>provide a signal strength. It is always set to 0.
>An Equalizer/Phase Tracker Mean Square Error value is
>available VSB. Only Phase Tracker MSE is available for QAM.
>This can be converted to signal to noise ratio (SNR) in db
>with the formula:
>where log is base 10 and MSE is either of the two readings.
>For the lgdt3303 one reading is 19 bits long and the other
>is 20 bits long. For the lgdt3302 both values are 19 bits
>long, but the formulas are different from that above.
>Unfortunately the variable used to return the result is
>unsigned 16 bits long so the values must be truncated.
>lgdt330x driver returns the truncated raw MSE value.
>If the variable were longer the full value could be returned
>without arbitrary truncation.
>If the variable were signed the driver could return the SNR
>value in db. It must be signed because the formula returns
>a negative value when the signal is less than the noise or
>a positive value when the signal is greater than the noise.
>The calculation is made using lookup tables since floating
>point math is not allowed in kernel drivers.
...so I don't know if that's gonna happen anytime soon. At least it
More information about the linux-dvb