[vdr] VDR 1.3.38 and "-u root"
Klaus Schmidinger
Klaus.Schmidinger at cadsoft.de
Thu Jan 12 09:32:10 CET 2006
Andreas Holzhammer - GMX wrote:
> Joachim Wilke schrieb:
>
>> 2006/1/10, Ludwig Nussel <ludwig.nussel at suse.de
>> <mailto:ludwig.nussel at suse.de>>:
>>
>> I vote for automatically using user vdr when started as root to
>> promote the unprivileged user mode and to emphasize that using root
>> is not recommended.
>>
>> I would prefer a secure default setting too. Experienced users, or
>> people who think they are, can override it on the commandline, so
>> nobody is forced to use the secure default.
>>
>> Joachim.
>
>
> IMHO a program should always run as the user who invoked it, unless told
> otherwise. Silently changing the userid does look very counterintuitive
> to me.
>
> But then I'm a strong believer in "do what i told you", no "do what you
> think is the best for me", especially when it comes to computers.
>
> Andreas
I'll make it so that it runs under the user id of the caller,
and only sets it to a different one if the caller is 'root' and
the '-u' option is given (with a different user name than 'root').
For Ludwig Nussl there will be a Make.config option ;-)
Klaus
More information about the vdr
mailing list