Hello,
i've a Twinhan VisionPlus DVB with CI and AlphaCrypt light (linux-2.6.14, vdr-1.3.37). When i start vdr, syslogs says:
|Nov 30 10:19:53 localhost kernel: dst_put_ci: Put Command |Nov 30 10:19:53 localhost kernel: ca_get_slot_caps: -->dst_put_ci SUCCESS ! |Nov 30 10:19:53 localhost kernel: ca_get_slot_caps: Slot cap = [5] |Nov 30 10:19:53 localhost kernel: =================================== |Nov 30 10:19:53 localhost kernel: 18 64 0 0 2 11 0 5 |Nov 30 10:19:53 localhost kernel: dst_ca_ioctl: -->CA_GET_CAP Success ! |Nov 30 10:19:53 localhost vdr[4107]: CAM doesn't support link layer interface |Nov 30 10:19:53 localhost kernel: dst_ca_release: Device closed.
Is it a driver or a vdr problem and can it be solved? The CAM works fine in a FuSi DVB-C card.
Is it a driver or a vdr problem and can it be solved? The CAM works fine in a FuSi DVB-C card.
This is probably a driver problem. From what I have seen in the archives of the linuxtv mailinglist, cam support has been fixed for this device only recently in CVS.
Best regards,
Maarten Wisse
On Wed, Nov 30, 2005 at 12:00:24PM +0100, Maarten Wisse wrote:
Is it a driver or a vdr problem and can it be solved? The CAM works fine in a FuSi DVB-C card.
This is probably a driver problem. From what I have seen in the archives of the linuxtv mailinglist, cam support has been fixed for this device only recently in CVS.
Thanx for the hint. I've checked out the driver from CVS but no luck:
|Nov 30 12:19:01 localhost kernel: dst_ca_open: Device opened [d68a92c0] |Nov 30 12:19:01 localhost kernel: dst_ca_ioctl: Getting Slot capabilities |Nov 30 12:19:01 localhost kernel: put_checksum: Computing string checksum. |Nov 30 12:19:01 localhost kernel: put_checksum: -> string length : 0x07 |Nov 30 12:19:01 localhost kernel: put_checksum: -> checksum : 0xb5 |Nov 30 12:19:01 localhost kernel: dst_put_ci: Put Command |Nov 30 12:19:01 localhost kernel: ca_get_slot_caps: -->dst_put_ci SUCCESS ! |Nov 30 12:19:01 localhost kernel: ca_get_slot_caps: Slot cap = [5] |Nov 30 12:19:01 localhost kernel: =================================== |Nov 30 12:19:01 localhost kernel: 18 64 0 0 2 11 0 5 |Nov 30 12:19:01 localhost kernel: dst_ca_ioctl: -->CA_GET_CAP Success ! |Nov 30 12:19:01 localhost vdr[8492]: CAM doesn't support link layer interface |Nov 30 12:19:01 localhost kernel: dst_ca_release: Device closed.
On Wed, Nov 30, 2005 at 12:28:07PM +0100, Stefan Hußfeldt wrote:
On Wed, Nov 30, 2005 at 12:00:24PM +0100, Maarten Wisse wrote:
Is it a driver or a vdr problem and can it be solved? The CAM works fine in a FuSi DVB-C card.
This is probably a driver problem. From what I have seen in the archives of the linuxtv mailinglist, cam support has been fixed for this device only recently in CVS.
Thanx for the hint. I've checked out the driver from CVS but no luck:
...
|Nov 30 12:19:01 localhost vdr[8492]: CAM doesn't support link layer interface
Twinhan cards don't support CI link layer, only some CI application layer protocol. If at all, it only works with the ca_zap test program from dvb-apps CVS. VDR doesn't support this yet.
Johannes
On Wed, Nov 30, 2005 at 01:44:50PM +0100, Johannes Stezenbach wrote:
|Nov 30 12:19:01 localhost vdr[8492]: CAM doesn't support link layer interface
Twinhan cards don't support CI link layer, only some CI application layer protocol. If at all, it only works with the ca_zap test program from dvb-apps CVS. VDR doesn't support this yet.
OK, so i think the chance to get this card working with vdr is very small.
So now i'am looking for a recommendation for a DVB-S budget card with CI that works with vdr. Can i buy a WinTV-NOVA-CI-S (Modell 588)? vdr-wiki says yes.
On Wed, 2005-11-30 at 15:10 +0100, Stefan Hußfeldt wrote:
So now i'am looking for a recommendation for a DVB-S budget card with CI that works with vdr. Can i buy a WinTV-NOVA-CI-S (Modell 588)? vdr-wiki says yes.
I'm looking for similar experiences/recommendations for a budget DVB-C card. Anyone got the TT budget DVB-C (C1500) + budget CI (+ Conax CAM) combo working with VDR?
On Wednesday 30 November 2005 15:34, Ville Skyttä wrote:
On Wed, 2005-11-30 at 15:10 +0100, Stefan Hußfeldt wrote:
So now i'am looking for a recommendation for a DVB-S budget card with CI that works with vdr. Can i buy a WinTV-NOVA-CI-S (Modell 588)? vdr-wiki says yes.
I'm looking for similar experiences/recommendations for a budget DVB-C card. Anyone got the TT budget DVB-C (C1500) + budget CI (+ Conax CAM) combo working with VDR?
I'd like to have the twinhan ci cards working in vdr, because they are my only chance to have two dvb cards in one box. i've heard there is a library that should do the work. Would it be difficult to support that in vdr? Best
Maarten
Maarten Wisse wrote:
I'd like to have the twinhan ci cards working in vdr, because they are my only chance to have two dvb cards in one box. i've heard there is a library that should do the work. Would it be difficult to support that in vdr?
It is just a matter that somebody adds support to VDR in the lines of ca_zap or VLC, or even something different in a VDR specific way. Earlier, there was a discussion that Klaus mentioned that he would be interested in adding support, but there was no further development on that.
Manu
Johannes Stezenbach wrote:
If at all, it only works with the ca_zap test program from dvb-apps CVS.
VLC does work ATM http://trac.videolan.org/vlc/changeset/13469
Manu
-
Johannes Stezenbach -
Maarten Wisse -
Manu Abraham -
Stefan Hußfeldt -
Ville Skyttä