I observed that marks.vdr seems not to be compatible between vdr 1.2.6 and 1.3.44, in 1.3.44 the marks seem to be behind their correct position about a few minutes.
(i'am using analogtv plugin for recordings, not sat) The following applies: (ok= marks in correct position, not ok= marks wrong)
Recording made with 1.2.6, played with 1.2.6 = ok Recording made with 1.3.44, played with 1.2.6 = ok Recording made with 1.2.6, played with 1.3.44 = not ok Recording made with 1.3.44, played with 1.3.44 = not ok
So the error/change may not be in noad nor in analogtv - or is my logic wrong?
(used noad 0.71 but was same with older noad, with 1.2.6 i have a much older analogtv plugin than with 1.3.44 but the recordings are interoperable so i assume no relevant change and it might not a failure of noad either)
Hi,
Guido Fiala wrote:
I observed that marks.vdr seems not to be compatible between vdr 1.2.6 and 1.3.44, in 1.3.44 the marks seem to be behind their correct position about a few minutes.
Do you really mean minutes?
(i'am using analogtv plugin for recordings, not sat) The following applies: (ok= marks in correct position, not ok= marks wrong)
Recording made with 1.2.6, played with 1.2.6 = ok Recording made with 1.3.44, played with 1.2.6 = ok Recording made with 1.2.6, played with 1.3.44 = not ok Recording made with 1.3.44, played with 1.3.44 = not ok
So the error/change may not be in noad nor in analogtv - or is my logic wrong?
(used noad 0.71 but was same with older noad, with 1.2.6 i have a much older analogtv plugin than with 1.3.44 but the recordings are interoperable so i assume no relevant change and it might not a failure of noad either)
Would you please explain, how you did check the correctness?
E. g. do you see a different image, when you position to the same cutting mark under 1.2.6 respectively 1.3.44?
Bye.
On Sunday 26 March 2006 17:34, Reinhard Nissl wrote:
Guido Fiala wrote:
I observed that marks.vdr seems not to be compatible between vdr 1.2.6 and 1.3.44, in 1.3.44 the marks seem to be behind their correct position about a few minutes.
Do you really mean minutes?
Yes, of course the error is cummulative, the first mark is off about 5 minutes (full length of advertising), the next more and so on.
(i'am using analogtv plugin for recordings, not sat) The following applies: (ok= marks in correct position, not ok= marks wrong)
Recording made with 1.2.6, played with 1.2.6 = ok Recording made with 1.3.44, played with 1.2.6 = ok Recording made with 1.2.6, played with 1.3.44 = not ok Recording made with 1.3.44, played with 1.3.44 = not ok
So the error/change may not be in noad nor in analogtv - or is my logic wrong?
(used noad 0.71 but was same with older noad, with 1.2.6 i have a much older analogtv plugin than with 1.3.44 but the recordings are interoperable so i assume no relevant change and it might not a failure of noad either)
Would you please explain, how you did check the correctness?
I made recordings and let noad run and the cutting marks did not fit under 1.3.44, then i stopped vdr and started 1.2.6 and checked the same recording without touching the marks.vdr file and now the marks are at the correct position. The same procedure the other way around...
E. g. do you see a different image, when you position to the same cutting mark under 1.2.6 respectively 1.3.44?
Yes, different point in video-stream while viewing the progressbar, it seems the marks are moved to the right in the progressbar under 1.3.44 or the "actual position point" is to the left.
How can i further track down this?
Guido
Hi,
Guido Fiala wrote:
I observed that marks.vdr seems not to be compatible between vdr 1.2.6 and 1.3.44, in 1.3.44 the marks seem to be behind their correct position about a few minutes.
Do you really mean minutes?
Yes, of course the error is cummulative, the first mark is off about 5 minutes (full length of advertising), the next more and so on.
(i'am using analogtv plugin for recordings, not sat) The following applies: (ok= marks in correct position, not ok= marks wrong)
Recording made with 1.2.6, played with 1.2.6 = ok Recording made with 1.3.44, played with 1.2.6 = ok Recording made with 1.2.6, played with 1.3.44 = not ok Recording made with 1.3.44, played with 1.3.44 = not ok
So the error/change may not be in noad nor in analogtv - or is my logic wrong?
(used noad 0.71 but was same with older noad, with 1.2.6 i have a much older analogtv plugin than with 1.3.44 but the recordings are interoperable so i assume no relevant change and it might not a failure of noad either)
Would you please explain, how you did check the correctness?
I made recordings and let noad run and the cutting marks did not fit under 1.3.44, then i stopped vdr and started 1.2.6 and checked the same recording without touching the marks.vdr file and now the marks are at the correct position. The same procedure the other way around...
E. g. do you see a different image, when you position to the same cutting mark under 1.2.6 respectively 1.3.44?
Yes, different point in video-stream while viewing the progressbar, it seems the marks are moved to the right in the progressbar under 1.3.44 or the "actual position point" is to the left.
How can i further track down this?
I've just recorded two DVB-S samples with one commercial break, one with VDR-1.2.6 and one with VDR-1.3.44 and let noad-0.6.0 create marks.vdr.
Besides two false positives, the cutting marks for the commercial breaks were correct for both recordings in any of the above four test cases.
Bye.
Zitat von Reinhard Nissl rnissl@gmx.de:
(i'am using analogtv plugin for recordings, not sat) The following applies: (ok= marks in correct position, not ok= marks wrong)
Recording made with 1.2.6, played with 1.2.6 = ok Recording made with 1.3.44, played with 1.2.6 = ok Recording made with 1.2.6, played with 1.3.44 = not ok Recording made with 1.3.44, played with 1.3.44 = not ok
So the error/change may not be in noad nor in analogtv - or is my logic wrong?
I've just recorded two DVB-S samples with one commercial break, one with VDR-1.2.6 and one with VDR-1.3.44 and let noad-0.6.0 create marks.vdr.
Besides two false positives, the cutting marks for the commercial breaks were correct for both recordings in any of the above four test cases.
Which means, it must be related to the analogtv-plugin :-( Maybe the cvs-Version is broken?
Has someone a working version of the analogtv-plugin with 1.3.44 regarding this problem?
Hi,
gfiala@s.netic.de wrote:
(i'am using analogtv plugin for recordings, not sat) The following applies: (ok= marks in correct position, not ok= marks wrong)
Recording made with 1.2.6, played with 1.2.6 = ok Recording made with 1.3.44, played with 1.2.6 = ok Recording made with 1.2.6, played with 1.3.44 = not ok Recording made with 1.3.44, played with 1.3.44 = not ok
So the error/change may not be in noad nor in analogtv - or is my logic wrong?
I've just recorded two DVB-S samples with one commercial break, one with VDR-1.2.6 and one with VDR-1.3.44 and let noad-0.6.0 create marks.vdr.
Besides two false positives, the cutting marks for the commercial breaks were correct for both recordings in any of the above four test cases.
Which means, it must be related to the analogtv-plugin :-( Maybe the cvs-Version is broken?
Has someone a working version of the analogtv-plugin with 1.3.44 regarding this problem?
Well, I currently have no working setup, but maybe next weekend I could try analogtv-plugin once again.
Bye.
-
gfiala＠s.netic.de -
Guido Fiala
-
Reinhard Nissl